Putting meditation to the test - New Scientist

Hey all,

Here’s a good article from New Scientist on the benefits of meditation – again something I must make time for given the benefits. I know myself how wrapped up in work and routine I can get and how that in itself is probably not good for keeping a happy stress-free body and thus increasing migraine threshold. It’s a long read but a good one.

Scott 8)

[size=130]Mind gym: Putting meditation to the test[/size]

Mystics will tell you that meditation transforms the mind and soothes the soul. But what does science have to say?

MANY people see meditation as an exotic form of daydreaming, or a quick fix for a stressed-out mind. My advice to them is, try it. It’s difficult, at least to begin with. On my first attempt, instead of concentrating on my breathing and letting go of anything that came to mind as instructed by my cheery Tibetan teacher, I got distracted by a string of troubled thoughts and then fell asleep. Apparently this is normal for first-timers.

Experienced meditators will assure you that it is worth persisting, however. “Training allows us to transform the mind, to overcome destructive emotions and to dispel suffering,” says Buddhist monk Matthieu Ricard. “The numerous and profound methods that Buddhism has developed over the centuries can be used and incorporated by anyone. What is needed is enthusiasm and perseverance.” It all sounds very rewarding, but what does science have to say on the subject?

Stories abound in the media about the transformative potential of meditative practice, but it is only in recent years that empirical evidence has emerged. In the past decade, researchers have used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to look at the brains of experienced meditators such as Ricard as well as beginners, and tested the effects of different meditative practices on cognition, behaviour, physical and emotional health and brain plasticity. A real scientific picture of meditation is now coming together. It suggests that meditation can indeed change aspects of your psychology, temperament and physical health in dramatic ways. The studies are even starting to throw light on how meditation works.

“Time spent earnestly investigating the nature of your mind is bound to be helpful,” says Clifford Saron at the Center for Mind and Brain at the University of California, Davis. And you don’t need a Buddhist or spiritualist world view to profit from meditation. “One can be an empiricist [in meditation], just by working with the nature of your experience.” Saron should know - he is leading the Shamatha project, one of the most comprehensive scientific studies of meditation ever.

In 2007, Saron and a team of neuroscientists and psychologists followed 60 experienced meditators over an intensive three-month meditation retreat in the Colorado Rockies, watching for changes in their mental abilities, psychological health and physiology. The participants practised for at least five hours a day using a method known as focused attention meditation, which involves directing attention on the tactile sensation of breathing (see “How to meditate”). The first paper from the project was published in June 2010 (Psychological Science, vol 21, p 829).

Headed by Katherine MacLean at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine in Baltimore, the study measured the volunteers’ attention skills by showing them a succession of vertical lines flashed up on a computer screen. They then had to indicate, by clicking a mouse, whenever there was a line shorter than the rest. As the retreat progressed, MacLean and her colleagues noted that the volunteers became progressively more accurate and found it increasingly easy to stay focused on the task for long periods.

Other researchers have also linked meditation with improved attention. Last year a team led by Antoine Lutz at the Waisman Laboratory for Brain Imaging and Behavior, which is part of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, reported that after three months of training in focused attention meditation, volunteers were quicker at picking out different tones among a succession of similar ones, implying their powers of sustained concentration had improved (Journal of Neuroscience, vol 29, p 13418). In 2007, Lutz’s colleague Heleen Slagter, now at the University of Amsterdam in the Netherlands, published results from a study involving a combination of focused attention and “open monitoring” or mindfulness meditation - which involves the constant monitoring of moment-by-moment experience. After three months of meditation for between 10 and 12 hours a day her subjects showed a decreased “attentional blink”, the cognitive processing delay, usually lasting about half a second, that causes people to miss a stimulus such as a number on a screen when it follows rapidly after another (PLoS Biology, vol 5, p e128).

The suggestion that meditation can improve attention is worth considering, given that focus is crucial to so much in life, from the learning and application of skills to everyday judgement and decision-making, or simply concentrating on your computer screen at work without thinking about what you will be eating for dinner. But how does dwelling on your breath for a period each day lead to such a pronounced cognitive change?

One possibility is that it involves working memory, the capacity to hold in mind information needed for short-term reasoning and comprehension. The link with meditation was established recently by Amishi Jha at the University of Miami in Coral Gables. She trained a group of American marines to focus their attention using mindfulness meditation and found that this increased their working memory (Emotion, vol 10, p 54). MacLean points out that meditation is partly about observing how our sensory experiences change from moment to moment, which requires us to hold information about decaying sensory traces in working memory.

MacLean and others also believe that meditation training enhances some central cognitive faculty - as yet unknown - that is used in all basic perception tasks. “It’s like a muscle that can be used in lots of different ways,” she says. Then, once perception becomes less effortful, the brain can direct more of its limited resources to concentration. Backing up this idea, Slagter’s measurements of electrical activity in the brain during the attentional blink task revealed that as meditation training progressed, volunteers used fewer resources when processing the first stimulus, meaning they were less likely to get “stuck” on it and miss the second stimulus.

[size=130]Feeling Better[/size]

Along with enhancing cognitive performance, meditation seems to have an effect on emotional well-being. A second study from researchers with the Shamatha project, to appear in the journal Emotion, concluded that meditation improves general social and emotional functioning, making study participants less anxious, and more aware of and better able to manage their emotions.

A clue about how this might work comes from the finding that the volunteers also got better at a task in which they had to look at a screen and click a mouse whenever a long line appeared but resist the urge to click at the appearance of shorter lines. This is harder than it sounds, especially as the shorter lines appear infrequently. Lead author Baljinder Sahdra, at the University of California, Davis, reasons that meditation training teaches people to “withhold impulsive reactions to a lot of internal stimuli, some of which can be emotionally intense in nature”, adding that this kind of restraint seems to be a key feature of healthy emotion regulation.

The notion that by practising meditation people become less emotionally reactive is also reinforced by brain imaging work. A team led by Julie Brefczynski-Lewis at West Virginia University in Morgantown used fMRI to study meditators “in action” and found that the amygdala - which plays a crucial role in processing emotions and emotional memories - was far less active in expert meditators than in novices (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol 104, p 11483).

The ability to manage one’s emotions could also be key to why meditation can improve physical health. Studies have shown it to be an effective treatment for eating disorders, substance abuse, psoriasis and in particular for recurrent depression and chronic pain. Last year, psychologist Fadel Zeidan, at Wake Forest University School of Medicine in Winston-Salem, reported that his volunteers noticed a decreased sensitivity to pain after just a few sessions of mindfulness meditation (Journal of Pain, vol 11, p 199). He believes meditation doesn’t remove the sensation of pain so much as teach sufferers to control their emotional reaction to it and reduce the stress response. He is now using fMRI in an attempt to understand why that helps. “There’s something very empowering about knowing you can alleviate some of these things yourself,” he says.

— Begin quote from ____

“Volunteers noticed a decreased sensitivity to pain after just a few sessions of meditation”

— End quote

The positive effect of meditation on psychological well-being could also explain recent findings from the Shamatha project that regular meditation practice can lead to a significant increase in the activity of telomerase, an enzyme that protects against cellular ageing and which is suppressed in response to psychological stress. The work will appear in Psychoneuroendocrinology.

Emotions may also be at the heart of another benefit of meditation. One of the hottest areas in meditation research is whether the practice can enhance feelings towards others. This arose partly because fMRI studies by Lutz and his team showed that brain circuits linked to empathy and the sharing of emotions - such as the insula and the anterior cingulate cortex - are much more active in long-term meditators than in novices (NeuroImage, vol 47, p 1038).

— Begin quote from ____

“One of the hottest areas in meditation research is whether it can enhance feelings towards others.”

— End quote

Compassion is a complicated construct that probably involves a host of emotional skills according to Margaret Kemeny at the University of California, San Francisco. “To be compassionate with someone, first you have to recognise that they are experiencing a negative reaction. Then you have to consider what a beneficial response might be. Then you have to have the motivation to do something about it.” In other words, you are unlikely to increase someone’s capacity for compassion without improving their emotional balance.

[size=130]A Gym For Your Mind[/size]

In 2009, an institute dedicated to studying the neurobiological roots of empathy and compassion opened at Stanford University in California. The Center for Compassion and Altruism Research and Education, which is funded by a range of interest groups including neuroscientists, Silicon Valley entrepreneurs and the Dalai Lama, has already instigated a clutch of studies. They aim to discover how a special kind of meditation training in which the practitioner focuses on enhancing their altruistic love for others affects the brain, and the extent to which it can cultivate empathic and compassionate feelings and behaviour.

The suggestion that people can become more empathic and compassionate through meditation practice has prompted psychologist Paul Ekman and Alan Wallace, a Buddhist teacher and president of the Santa Barbara Institute for Consciousness Studies, to float the idea of mental training “gymnasiums”. Like physical exercise gyms, but for the mind, these would allow people to drop in and learn to improve their emotional balance, develop their capacity for compassion and even measure their stress levels.

Others have suggested that meditation could become an alternative to medication. Although this seems like a good idea, Saron is dubious. He worries that thinking of meditation as a quick fix will smother some of the subtleties that are integral to successful practice. “When you are returning your mind to the object in hand, you have to do it with a sense of gentleness and authority, rather than develop a sense of failure when your mind wanders.”

But the great thing about meditation is that anyone can practise it anywhere. What’s more you don’t have to be an expert or spend five hours a day at it to reap the benefits. The novices in Zeidan’s pain experiment reported improvements after meditating for just 20 minutes a day for three days. In a second experiment he found that similarly brief sessions can improve cognitive performance on tasks that demand continuous attention, such as remembering and reciting a series of digits (Consciousness and Cognition, vol 19, p 597). “It is possible to produce substantial changes in brain function through short-term practice of meditation,” says Richard Davidson, director of the Waisman Laboratory. He says data from a new unpublished study by his lab shows “demonstrable changes in brain function” in novice meditators after just two weeks of training for 30 minutes a day. “Even small amounts of practice can make a discernible difference.”

That is good news for beginners like me. Still, it does seem that the more you meditate, the greater the impact on your brain. Research by Brefczynski-Lewis, for example, revealed changes in brain activity indicating that expert meditators require minimal cognitive effort to stay focused. But this particular effect was only evident in people who had spent around 44,000 hours meditating - that’s the equivalent of working for 25 years at a full-time job. Most of us will probably never achieve that level of transcendence but it’s certainly something to aim for.

[size=130]How To Meditate[/size]

There are numerous meditation styles, but the two most commonly studied by researchers are focused attention meditation, in which the aim is to stay focused on a chosen thing such as an icon, a mantra or the breath, and mindfulness or open monitoring meditation, where practitioners try to become aware of everything that comes into their moment-by-moment experience without reacting to it.

For focused attention meditation, start by sitting on a cushion or chair with your back straight and your hands in your lap and eyes closed. Then concentrate your mind on your chosen object - say your breathing, or more particularly the sensation of your breath leaving your mouth or nostrils. Try to keep it there. Probably your mind will quickly wander away, to an itch on your leg, perhaps, or to thoughts of what you will be doing later. Keep bringing it back to the breath. In time this will train the mind in three essential skills: to watch out for distractions, to “let go” of them once the mind has wandered, and to re-engage with the object of meditation. With practice, you should find it becomes increasingly easy to stay focused.

In mindfulness meditation the aim is to monitor all the various experiences of your mind - thoughts, emotions, bodily sensations - and simply observe them, rather than trying to focus on any one of them. Instead of grasping at whatever comes to mind, which is what most of us do most of the time, the idea is to maintain a detached awareness. Those who develop this skill find it easier to manage emotions in day-to-day life.

The more you practise, the deeper the changes will be. As Buddhist teacher Alan Wallace puts it: “You have now set out on one of the greatest expeditions as you explore the hidden recesses of your mind.”


  1. Mind in the Balance by Alan Wallace (Columbia University Press, 2009)
  2. The Art of Meditation by Matthieu Ricard (Atlantic Books, 2010)

Hey Scott,

If you find a book which works for you, let me know. I have been interested in the Buddhist religion and meditation for a long time. Have got books from the library and tried to meditate but I just cant seem to go there. I still try, I always try to focus on a pebble (I thought that couldnt be destracting :? ) I am very aware that I think about everything too much, analyse it, work out why, compare, etc. Also the stress thing, I can actually feel myself getting stressed over say "trying to find something on the computer and 3 hours later, still, trying to find something better than the first, where someone else would pick the first and be done with it.

I made one New Years resolution this year, to try and avoid stress more. A good one, dont you think?


I’d been using breath meditation fairly religiously while swimming, but at the moment don’t have a good perspective on how effective it was, as Monday while swimming I lost track, in the sense that I left the gym realizing that I had quit well before I had intended to. It’s been a bad few days, with a lot of fuzzy-headedness intruding, and culminated in my sort of blanking out and sliding down today, fortunately not striking anything but my butt. Something I ate? I have a slight suspect. Change in weather? Might have contributed. Physical discomfort, maybe a bit, from adding PT exercises on to swimming. Life stress, surely. Some from focusing hard on preparing a presentation whose responsibility landed on me, and from worrying about deterioration in my mother’s thinking ability/memory. Meditation experience hasn’t protected me from responding to all this. But this is a different kind of test.
(Sorry for the rant, but not sorry enough to erase it.)

I have never had formal instructions on meditation, but I have had a couple of therapists and docs recommend “relaxation” exercises. I’ve been given a few audio discs and it turns out that what they wanted me to try was meditation under a different name. I’m not even going to say that I am good at it, but I have developed a technique through meditation/relaxation where I can restore several minutes of balance in just a few seconds. From the little bit that I am able to do quickly, I imagine that if I were to get some formal instruction and practice it daily I wouldn’t be wound so tight.

I bet the Dalai Lama and some uber meditator types can have major control over their brain waves.

I bet us “mere mortals” can achieve significant changes in our brain waves with focus on the breath. It would seem that anything we can do to bring on more calmness on a daily basis - psychologically and physiologically - might make it at least a little less likely that our migraine brains would reach the threshold for “going off.”

That’s why I asked Scott a few weeks ago about studies on yoga & migraine (yoga, for those who haven’t tried it, may look like it’s all about twisting you into a pretzel but there’s a huge focus on deep breathing). Meditation is along the same lines. I’ve read about walking meditation - never heard about it in re swimming, but that’s really a perfect fit, David. (So sorry to hear you’re dealing with your Mom’s cognitive problems - been there, done that, and it’s extremely stressful.)

I bought a gentle yoga DVD which just arrived, but my problem is finding time to do it, with all the overtime I’m having to put in lately… :?

I have been practicing mindfulness meditation for almost a year now, and it really helps in dealing with this chronic disease. I found it was best to take the 8 week “Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction” class at my local hospital to really get into it properly and develop a regular practice.

It’s wonderful to go to a place of peace and quiet after a day of struggling with motion sickness!

1 Like

Unfortunately the links in the original post no longer work. The original article is however still available but unfortunately only by subscription for interested parties. I bumped it up because its a useful thread for anybody looking at Meditation. The first other half decent internet post I found on Mindfulness Meditation started off suggesting we commenced by chewing a square of chocolate mindfully! Not really for MAVers I thought that one.

Over the years I’ve tried any ‘alternative therapies, but didn’t think Mindfulness Meditation was amongst them. I now discover it encompasses ‘Deep Muscle Relaxation’ and I did a lot of that through one winter I now recall. It was slightly relaxing but I don’t recall it ever released tight neck muscles caused by the migraine/vertigo. My sister in law whose trained in massage/aromatherapy style tells me there’s a build up of lactic acid involved there somewhere and the only way to shift that is hands on massage, and heat/cold. Of course Mindfulness Meditation appears to encompass a much wider spectrum than Deep Muscle Mediation and could be beneficial for some. Personally I fell down with the Visual Imagery but we are all different. Helen



How do you do meditation when you’re unbalanced and feeling rocking and swaying most of the time.

You need to stabilise yourself first before doing anything like meditation. It’s a cherry on top, a nice to have so not a first line of defence.

If you ever wind up in A&E you will notice a distinct lack of patients practicing yoga and knocking back green smoothies.

Got to disagree with you there Andy. ‘Waiting until you are stabilised’ for many if not most people is like waiting for tomorrow. It never comes. And meditation can be prescribed for some very early on, before meds start even. I was ‘prescribed’ CBT initially which did me neither good nor harm I see no reason not to try meditation when acute. Some forms are very relaxed, you can do them sitting down with/without closed eyes depending on individual triggers. You don’t necessarily have to be sitting upright and cross legged on the floor. It’s a question of finding a type that your own current disabilities can cope with.

Whether meditation is a good idea is another question. I remember @ander454 saying he found it made his dizziness much more apparent and I feel sure it pushes people deeper into themselves and their own feelings although I appreciate they should really be thinking of ‘nothing’. That’s near impossible to achieve. I feel what tends to happen is people sit still and instead of clearing their mind tend to dwell on the enormities of the condition and end up constantly reliving the trauma involved and looking out for the next wobble/spin etc which defeats the object. Perhaps some absorbing hobby/distraction/way of keeping busy might prove more beneficial than attempting meditation in the first place. Must admit I gave up on meditation. Deep Muscle Relaxation and certain exercises OK. Doing something is easier than doing nothing. Sure is.

When it comes to people in A&E practising yoga. Perhaps not in the Waiting Area. No I’ve not seen one either though I’ve sat in an A&E ward cubicle doing Tai Chi several times. And I’ve sat in a hospital bed waiting to go to theatre doing Tai Chi. Helen

1 Like

I find it to be piss farting around the edges so we have to agree to disagree :grimacing:

You are obviously still blissfully unaware of the vast impact both physically and psychologically MAV can have on some people. For many it is totally devastating. They need both medication and emotional support to get through it. For some both can prove essential.


Again, not a first line of defence. Can benefits be had from it, sure. When they are treating someone with acute injuries / symptoms with mindfulness… get back to me.

Add me to that list. It has totaly ruined the last 5 years of my life with no end in sight as of yet and thats with treatment and medication
Jo x


It’s totally destroyed my life but meditation isn’t bringing that shit back unless I’m missing all the success stories about it.

If something isn’t working, cut it loose and move on. The current medication & treatment options aren’t fit for purpose.

I couldnt survive without Botox Injections Andy…so that is a treatment that"s fit for purpose…well in my case anyhow. But struggle badly still with vestibular symptoms


Don’t give up guys. Have faith…that’s the only thing that keeps me going and my family…


I’m glad Botox works for you Jo but still… sticking poison in yourself isn’t the way to go. The medical industry is grasping at straws.

I’ve said in previous posts that I’m not against any medication or treatment if it helps an individual. I just don’t praise them either as they simply aren’t good enough. I understand when your quality of life has been decimated a drug that can offer ~50% back sounds pretty good… but it’s still a shitty deal.

Yes i agree it is a shitty deal but ive been that poorly and not able to go to work now for weeks im past caring what contents is in Botox…if it can give me a taste of normality im gonna grab it with both hands


With you there Jo!! :two_hearts: